Creamy and Dreamy Mac and Cheese

Mac and cheese is a classic comfort food that is beloved by many. This particular recipe for Creamy and Dreamy Mac and Cheese takes this staple to luxurious new heights. With creamy, melty white cheddar cheese and Parmesan, it is truly a decadent delight.

Overview

This mac and cheese recipe makes use of elbow macaroni and a rich, smooth cheese sauce made from milk, butter, and flour. Shredded sharp white Cheddar and grated Parmesan provide signature flavor, contributing to the dish’s creaminess. Topped with toasted, buttery breadcrumbs and a dash of paprika for visual flair, it is baked until hot and bubbling.

Part of what sets this baked macaroni and cheese apart is its emphasis on quality ingredients. Using excellent cheeses like aged white Cheddar and true Parmesan makes all the difference, taking the flavor up a notch. Equally important is allowing those cheeses to shine by not overcomplicating the sauce. This recipe keeps it simple but elegant.

From preparation to presentation, this mac and cheese is satisfying on multiple levels. The hands-on crafting of the sauce and assembly of each component, followed by the anticipation of oven-bubbling, makes the ultimate indulgence hard-earned. Visually, it is a stunner, with molten cheese peeking through toasted breadcrumbs here and there. The first creamy bite delivers big comfort. Every element works together in luxurious harmony.

Step-By-Step Instructions

Following the steps as written ensures Creamy Dreamy success. Before diving in, gather all necessary equipment and have ingredients measured out and ready to go.

Cook the Macaroni

Elbow macaroni works best since its curved shape catches the creamy sauce. Boil until just shy of al dente according to package instructions. Be careful not to overcook. Drain thoroughly once done.

Make the Cheese Sauce

First, melt the butter over medium heat. The small amount of flour thickens the sauce beautifully without dulling the cheese flavors. Whisking constantly, gradually add warmed milk and stir vigorously to prevent lumps from forming until the mixture is smooth.

Add the Cheeses

Introduce the cheeses a little at a time, allowing each addition to melt completely before moving on. This allows their flavors to build, preventing clumping. Stir, stir, stir!

Combine and Transfer

Gently fold in cooked macaroni with cheese sauce until every piece is thoroughly coated. Transfer to a greased baking dish. This protects the exterior edges from drying out while baking.

Toast the Breadcrumbs

In the same pan, melt additional butter. Toss in fresh breadcrumbs and toast to a light golden brown. This adds fantastic crunch and buttery richness.

Finish and Bake

Evenly sprinkle breadcrumbs over mac and cheese. A dash of paprika adds visual pop. Bake at 350°F for 30 minutes until hot and bubbling at edges. The interior should be hot and creamy while the crust remains crisp.

Choosing the Right Ingredients for Creamy and Dreamy Mac and Cheese

As mentioned, using quality ingredients makes all the difference in a simple recipe like mac and cheese. Here are some tips on selecting components for optimum flavor and texture.

Pasta

While any small pasta shape works, elbow macaroni is the gold standard with its perfect cheese-gripping curves. Seek out durum semolina pasta for best consistency and fewer tendency to overcook.

Cheeses

Splurge on the good stuff! Sharp white cheddar is key, ideally aged 12-24 months for sharpness. Freshly grated Parmesan adds nutty depth. Using processed cheeses ruins the entire dish.

Milk

Whole milk offers creaminess, while 2% or skim milk leads to a thinner sauce. For ultra-rich results, heavy cream boosts luxuriousness. Buttermilk is also delicious!

Butter

High-fat European style butters like Plugrá offer incomparable flavor over standard varieties. Clarified butter works too since its higher smoke point allows sautéing the flour longer before adding milk.

Breadcrumbs

Homemade fresh breadcrumbs are unbeatable, lending crunch and soaking up all the butter. Panko also does the trick. Avoid plain dry breadcrumbs.

Flavor Variations

While cheddar and Parmesan deliver that quintessential mac and cheese experience, you can incorporate additional flavors for your own signature twist:

Smoked Gouda or Provolone

Mix in gouda for smoky decadence or provolone for milky smoothness.

Blue or Gorgonzola

Crumble in bold blue cheese like Maytag or Gorgonzola for serious pungency.

Gruyère or Fontina

Nutty, alpine cheeses like Gruyère or Fontina lend sophisticated notes.

Cream Cheese

Stir in a few dollops of cream cheese just before baking for ultimate richness.

Caramelized Onions

Sautéed onions sweeten things up beautifully.

Bacon

Chopped, cooked bacon adds delightful crunch and salty contrast.

Making It Your Own

This dish invites creativity in preparation, serving, and presentation. Customize to your preferences for the ultimate bespoke mac and cheese.

Mix Ins

In addition to flavor mix-ins, add fun textural elements like cooked lobster meat, crisp fried shallots, broccoli florets, truffle shavings, or caviar.

Top Off

Along with toasted breadcrumbs, try garlic panko, chili crisp, crispy onions, pork rinds, or crumbled crackers on top.

Bakeware

For stunning presentation, use individual ramekins for single-serving macs. A vintage cast iron skillet or ceramic gratin dish also works nicely.

Plating

Serve mac and cheese in the vessel it was baked in for a rustic, imperfect look. Or transfer a wedge onto plates, topping it off just before serving.

Making Ahead & Leftovers

Part of the appeal of mac and cheese is being able to prepare components or the entire dish ahead of time. Properly stored, it keeps for several days.

Cook Ahead

Boil and drain pasta up to a day ahead. Rinse under cool water to prevent sticking then drizzle with olive oil and refrigerate in an airtight container.

Assemble Ahead

Make and combine cheese sauce with pasta, transfer to baking dish, and store covered for a day. Add breadcrumbs just before baking.

Bake Ahead

Fully prepare the casserole, but do not bake. Cover tightly and refrigerate for up to 2 days or freeze for longer duration. Thaw overnight before baking.

Reheat

Leftovers keep well for around 4 days. Reheat gently in the oven, adding a splash of milk or cream to restore creaminess as needed. The pasta soaks up sauce as it sits.

Occasions for Mac and Cheese

Beyond classic comfort food, this decadent mac and cheese has versatility for:

Weeknight Dinner

Easy to throw together on a weeknight, this satisfying mac offers quick clean up too. Serve with a crisp green salad.

Potlucks & Picnics

Its transportability makes mac and cheese a potluck and picnic staple. Make ahead, transfer to portable dish, and bake on site if possible.

Holiday Feasts

Offer this luxurious, crowd-pleasing mac and cheese alongside your holiday main course. It makes for fabulous leftovers too!

Date Nights In

Impress your date with ooey gooey from-scratch mac and cheese paired with wine, salad, and good conversation.

Kids’ Meals

Kids and grown ups alike adore mac and cheese! This version offers more nutrition and elevated flavor over boxed varieties.

Transforming an Iconic Dish

Macaroni and cheese enjoys icon status for good reason. At its best, the beloved dish conjures memories of the ultimate comfort food. This recipe for Creamy and Dreamy Mac and Cheese takes the nostalgic classic to new heights. With quality ingredients and decadent flavor combinations, it delivers luxury, satisfaction, and soul-warming happiness all in one bite. Part science, part simplicity, a whole lot of cheesy goodness!

Print